Thread:ScaryMovie53/@comment-4864110-20190228172819/@comment-30261954-20190703150717

ScaryMovie53 wrote: Theferretman21 wrote: ScaryMovie53 wrote: 'Theferretman21''': If you like, i can give you every reason i have to disagree. If there will be a reboot, with the same movies except with new cast, i would like to see the reboot version with the good things dropped from the canon. The DX spreading to the mainland and killing people, the raptors killing Spino-Rex, maybe having some novel characters come back, someone even had an idea where Jeff Rossiter from the novel (i assume he got into jail in the novel canon) comes back to mislead the heroes group... Many of those, and maybe more.''' Honestly thay sounds a lot more fantastical than this series has ever got. Even the far less realistic JW trilogy hasn't went down to "Velociraptors impossibly kill something 50 times their own size" that raptors keep falling into. And also, why would the good parts be dropped from canon? Why would you drop the Spinosaurus or new raptors but keep the talking dream raptor and Amanda?

Also, necroposting, look that up. I wouldn't call raptors killing Spino-Rex "unrealistic". It doesnt too realistic, but it's awesome. Know the rule of awesome? Sometimes, sheer awesomeness is all the reason you need to do things, not to mention they were geniuses. Think about it. Grant, a beloved character who went through decay and became a raptor-obssessed wreck, could get back on track and do what could've been the most amazing thing ever. This scene could've save the movie. And nope. I would never keep the talking raptor. I never said i would. Never said i would keep Amanda either. And here are the other points:

1. Necroposting isn't relevant between pen-mates. maybe i missunderstood the concept, but when i'm someone's pen-mate, we just talk whenever we have the time and wish to do so, and live our lives until one of us want to talk again. If necroposing matters anything, then me and that person weren't pen-mates to begin with.

2. "More fantastical than this series has ever got. Even the far less realistic JW trilogy hasn't went down to raptors killing something 50 times their own size" - Actually, JW onward was more realistic than JP3. First of all, the production. JP3 was infected with lazy writing and chaos. The characters weren't much, especially what they did to Grant. The JW characters were better, even without regarding the fact Owen is what Grant always wanted to be. If you'll bring the "t-rex fanboy" claim, i'll tell you that most people aren't upset about seeing the t-rex get killed. The upseting part is that Spino-Rex could'be been written much better. As powerful as he was, many of his over-powered qualities were more lazy writing than everything else. The movie just served everything right to his mouth. I know he was a super-powered hybrid, but he still got too many freebies. Another reason why dismissing the idea of raptors killing Spino-Rex is less of a point than it might sounds is that we had Blue and Rexy united against I-Rex and sent to Mossy's turf. It was awesome beyond words, and so would the genius raptors if they killed Spino-Rex. Seeing the good characters united to kill an allmighty villain is a good thing.

3. I'm not telling you not to like JP3. Just informing you with some of my reasons to see it as the lesser of JP/JW franchise.

Sorry if it came out aggressive. I just felt we have a mamenchisaurus-sized misunderstading, and i wanted to make things clear before it will escalate. Not numbered for some reaosn. Not in a franchise that has tried to make itself believable from the start, rule of awesome does not apply here.

1. There is a difference between a thread like this and some sorta private message wall, you wanna talk? Then make a new message on the message wall.

2a. That is the best thing I ever heard. For one the characters of JP3 are, imo, the best of the sequels. Grant has always been a better main character than Malcolm and has more depth even in 3 than Owen or Claire ever did. The Kirdy's were serviceable as well, and are better characters than anyone other than Lowery in the JW trilogy. I would say Amanda was bad, but since then I've experienced Franklin.

2b. And you just mentioned the biggest problem with the JW franchise, it wants to make us think the "normal" dinosaurs are now "good" while the hybrids are now "bad" instead of doing like the first trilogy did and keeping them as animals. The Spinosaurus vs raptors would've at least still been animal vs animal. Also, this goes against your point of realism...