User blog comment:Dinosaurus1/Everything wrong with CinemaSins' JW:FK video: In my opinion./@comment-30261954-20181216030211/@comment-30261954-20181216034030

"You missed the point, in that it was a joke, not a serious comment. Also,to quote Th3 Birdman during his Deadpool 2 and his Ready Player One video "the point is never that you have to read a book to understand a movie. The point is if you're going to criticize something, then you need to know what you're talking about, and that requires the knowledge of the source materiel" and "The books do matter. The point their making is that without the books, there wouldn't exist a movie". +3"

Treating them as separate mediums is how criticism is supposed to work. Also, why should I go read the comics of say Avengers Age of Ultron when I am criticizing the film? Seeing the source material does not make up for bland characters throughout most of the film and a nonthreatening villain to give two examples.

"Also, what are your thoughts on our other sins?"

This: "So far the only good parts of this have already been done."